The danger of heat and cold across Australia
Cold temperatures are not nearly as deadly as heat, with around two per cent of all deaths in Australia related to the latter, according to new research from the University of Technology Sydney (UTS), writes Leilah Schubert.
The new study looks at a national mortality data set, which allows for the analysis of differences between climate zones, in order to compare numbers of deaths from heat with those from cold. Credit: Martin Capek|123rf
The study, published in the journal Climatic Change, reveals that in warmer regions of Australia up to nine per cent of deaths were related to heat, with the elderly facing the greatest risk.
Cold weather had a much smaller impact (-0.4 per cent nationwide) except in the coldest climate zone, where 3.6 per cent of deaths could be linked to cold temperatures.
The study’s author Dr Thomas Longden, from the UTS Centre for Health Economics Research and Evaluation, explains the need for the research: "Accurately measuring temperature-related mortality is an important step towards understanding the impacts of climate change, particularly across different climate zones."
The study is the first to use a national data set of mortality records to calculate the number of deaths linked to heat and cold in Australia. A key part of the analysis was estimating temperature-related deaths across six climate zones.
The climate zones range from areas with hot, humid summers in Northern Australia, to areas with mild summers and cold winters in Tasmania, Australian Capital Territory (ACT) and parts of New South Wales (NSW) and Victoria.
The six climate zones formed the basis for the study, which aims to understand the impacts of climate change across Australia. Credit: Rainer Lesniewski|123rf
Regions with warm, humid summers, including Brisbane, Coffs Harbour and the Gold Coast, had the highest proportion of deaths linked to heat (9.1 per cent).
The coldest climate zone, which encompasses Tasmania and the NSW and Victorian alpine regions, saw 3.6 per cent of deaths attributed to cold temperatures and a 3.3 per cent reduction in deaths during warmer months.
The study also revealed that in some regions, particularly those with warm, humid summers, colder temperatures actually reduced deaths in comparison with the median temperature.
"While the cold is more dangerous in the colder climate zones, in four of the six regions, there was a decrease in deaths during colder weather. This is because most of the cold days in warmer climate zones are quite moderate," says Dr Longden.
Previous studies that used data for Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane have suggested that despite increasing temperatures owing to to climate change, there would be a net reduction in temperature-related deaths because of the reduction in cold-related deaths.
However, this study reveals that nationwide there would be a net cost from climate change, as increased heat-related deaths would not be offset by a reduction in cold-related deaths in most climate zones.
"Whether an increase in heat-related mortality is offset by a reduction in cold-related mortality is crucial to finding a net benefit or cost from climate change when using temperature-mortality relationships," Dr Longden says.
"The main differences between the earlier studies and this one is the use of a national mortality data set, which allows for the analysis of differences between climate zones, and the reference temperature used to measure the relative risk of mortality," adds Dr Longden.
Leilah Schubert, 12/09/2019